A section 75 payment is not a provisional credit
Chargeback and section 75 work differently after the money moves. A chargeback reverses a transaction through the card scheme, and the seller's bank can challenge it. The Financial Ombudsman Service states that chargebacks can fail, and that a first attempt may need to be taken further with more evidence. A section 75 payment is different. It settles a statutory liability. The creditor was jointly liable with the supplier for the breach, and the payment discharges that liability. The statute provides no mechanism for the creditor to reverse the payment through a scheme. That is the core difference between the two routes, and it is why section 75 is described as the stronger protection.
What can change after a claim is paid
A settled claim can still be revisited where the facts change. The most common case is late performance: the goods arrive after the refund, or the supplier performs the service after the claim was paid. The statute does not set out what happens then. The position turns on the facts, the terms of the settlement, and what the provider and the consumer agreed when the payment was made. Section 75(2) gives the creditor a right to be indemnified by the supplier for loss suffered in satisfying the liability. That indemnity runs between the creditor and the supplier. It does not create a right for the creditor to recover the payment from the consumer. A consumer who later receives the goods should tell the provider, because the record should reflect what actually happened.
If the provider changes its mind before paying
A claim that is rejected before payment is a different case from a payment that is reversed. A rejection can be challenged. The consumer should make a formal complaint to the provider, and if the response is unsatisfactory, take the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service. The ombudsman will look at whether the provider investigated properly, whether it considered the evidence, and whether its decision was fair. A provider can also change its own decision during the complaint process, where new evidence is produced. The entry records the route, not a prediction. A rejected claim is not a final answer, and a paid claim is not a provisional one.
How successful are section 75 claims
No regulator publishes a success rate for section 75 claims. The Financial Conduct Authority and the Financial Ombudsman Service publish complaints data, but not a figure for the proportion of section 75 claims that succeed. This entry therefore gives no percentage, because any figure would be invented. What can be said is what decides the outcome. The provider must find a debtor-creditor-supplier agreement, a single item cash price inside the band, and a breach of contract or misrepresentation by the supplier. Claims fail most often on the first of those three points, where the payment chain is broken by an intermediary, or on the second, where the item falls outside the price band. The third point turns on the evidence of what was promised and what was delivered.
The factors that decide the outcome
Five factors recur in the guidance. The first is the agreement link: was the credit arranged in connection with the purchase from that supplier. The second is the price: is the cash price of the single item above £100 and up to £30,000. The third is the breach: can the consumer show what the contract promised and how the supplier failed it. The fourth is the evidence: receipts, contracts, photographs and correspondence that prove the first three points. The fifth is timing: was the claim made while the evidence was fresh and the chargeback window still open. A claim that is strong on all five is hard to refuse. A claim that is weak on the first two cannot succeed however strong the complaint about the goods.
What a failed claim still leaves open
A failed section 75 claim does not remove the consumer's other rights. The claim against the supplier under the contract remains, and the Consumer Rights Act 2015 implies terms about satisfactory quality and reasonable care and skill into that contract. A chargeback may still be available where the payment was by card, though the time limit is short. A court claim remains open within the limitation period, generally six years in England and Wales. The Financial Ombudsman Service can also be asked to look at how the provider handled the claim, even where the underlying decision was correct. The ombudsman may find the handling unfair, for example where the provider took too long or failed to explain its reasons, and may direct the provider to put that right.
Asked of this entry
Can a section 75 claim be reversed?
No, not in the way a chargeback can be. A section 75 payment settles a statutory liability. The provider's assessment can change on new evidence, but the statute provides no reversal mechanism.
How successful are section 75 claims?
No regulator publishes a success rate, so this entry gives no figure. Outcomes turn on the agreement link, the price test, and the evidence of breach.
What happens if my section 75 claim is rejected?
Make a formal complaint to the provider. If the response is unsatisfactory, or no final response arrives within eight weeks, the complaint can go to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Authorities and record
Financial Ombudsman Service: section 75 and chargeback ↗Consumer Credit Act 1974, section 75 ↗Each authority is listed in its current version. Check national implementing measures and product facts before relying on a summary.