The payment chain decides the answer
Section 75 needs a debtor-creditor-supplier agreement. The debtor, the creditor and the supplier must be linked by arrangements that the section recognises. A payment provider sitting between the consumer and the supplier can break that link. The Financial Conduct Authority recorded this in its review of the Consumer Credit Act. Its report states that the use of third party payment processing firms has raised questions about whether the link survives, and that whether a debtor-creditor-supplier relationship exists depends on the specific arrangements and the effect of the commercial structures. The position varies between cases. No regulator or guide can settle the question for a particular purchase; that is a matter for a court. That uncertainty is the starting point for every payment provider question.
PayPal as a wallet
Paying with a linked card or a bank balance through a PayPal wallet usually breaks the direct link. The consumer's arrangement is with PayPal, and PayPal pays the supplier. The card provider's arrangement is with PayPal, not with the supplier of the goods. The Financial Conduct Authority model response on section 75 states that where arrangements between the card issuer and the supplier are broken by the involvement of an intermediary or third party in the payment chain, section 75 protection may not apply. The consumer in that position is not left without a route. PayPal has its own buyer protection process, and a chargeback may be available through the card scheme. Neither is section 75, and neither carries the same statutory force.
Guest checkout and the facts of the chain
Guest checkout, where the consumer pays by card without a PayPal account, is sometimes treated differently. The question is whether PayPal acted only as a payment processor passing the card payment to the supplier, or whether it stood between the parties as a separate payee. The answer turns on the receipts, the payment flow and the terms the consumer accepted. The Financial Ombudsman Service looks at how the purchase was made and the parties involved when it considers a complaint. A consumer who wants to preserve the position should keep the payment receipt and note who appears as the payee. A receipt showing the supplier as the payee supports the link. A receipt showing the payment provider as the payee weakens it.
PayPal Credit is a different arrangement
PayPal Credit is a separate credit product, offered under its own credit agreement. That makes it a different case from a wallet payment. Whether section 75 applies to a purchase made with PayPal Credit turns on the terms of that agreement and on whether a debtor-creditor-supplier relationship exists between the consumer, PayPal Credit and the supplier. This entry does not verify the terms of any single product. Product terms change, and the entry cannot state the position for a product it has not examined. A consumer considering a PayPal Credit purchase should read the credit agreement and check what it says about section 75. The general rule is that the agreement, not the brand name, decides the question.
Other payment providers and marketplaces
The same test applies to any intermediary in the payment chain. A payment app, a marketplace checkout, or a travel agent taking payment for a supplier all raise the same question: does a debtor-creditor-supplier relationship survive the arrangement? The Financial Conduct Authority identified travel agents as an example of the uncertainty in its 2019 review. The position is not that intermediaries always break the link. It is that the link must be examined in each case. A provider that merely processes the card payment is in a different position from a provider that takes the money as principal and then pays the supplier. The contract and the payment flow are the evidence.
How to keep the link intact
A consumer who wants the strongest section 75 position should pay the supplier directly by credit card where that is possible. The receipt should show the supplier as the payee. The card statement should show a payment to the supplier, not to a payment provider. Where a marketplace or wallet is the only way to pay, the consumer should keep the order confirmation, the payment receipt and the listing, and note the name of the seller. Those documents are what a provider or an ombudsman will ask for. The entry does not advise any individual on how to pay for a particular purchase. It records how the link is tested, so that the consumer can see the consequence of the payment method before choosing it.
Asked of this entry
Does section 75 apply if I pay by PayPal?
Usually not, where PayPal stands between the card provider and the supplier as a wallet payment. The position turns on the facts of the payment chain.
What is PayPal Credit under section 75?
PayPal Credit is a separate credit agreement. Whether section 75 applies turns on that agreement's terms and on whether a debtor-creditor-supplier relationship exists.
Can I still get a refund if section 75 does not apply?
Yes, other routes may exist. PayPal buyer protection, chargeback through the card scheme, and rights against the seller can all apply independently.
Authorities and record
FCA: how section 75 applies to travel services payments ↗Consumer Credit Act 1974, section 75 ↗Financial Ombudsman Service: section 75 and chargeback ↗Each authority is listed in its current version. Check national implementing measures and product facts before relying on a summary.